Did
You Know Series: (28): The Centenary of
the “Komagata Maru” Incident: Coins brought
out by the India Government Mints commemorating the occasion:
i)Rupees
One Hundred and Five Rupee (Proof & Uncirculated) sets for Collectors and ii)
Five Rupee Coin issued into general
circulation:
The
“Komagata Maru” Incident:
The
“Kamagata Maru” was one of the several incidents in the history of early
twentieth century involving laws in both Canada and the United States designed
to keep immigrants of Asian origin out.
The
discriminatory Canadian Immigration Laws:
In the early twentieth
century, Canada was accepting a large number of immigrants to settle their
territory.
The Canadian Government
was very keen to restrict immigration from Asia, particularly, from India, as
most of the applicants were British subjects and Indians, by and large, were
clamouring for Independence from British Rule leading to some stray incidents
involving violence against the British in India.
Apparently, the Government
of Britain which held the Canadian immigration portfolio at that time was
concerned about Indian nationals migrating to Canada and spreading their ideas
of Self-Governance/Independence to India, there.
As such, on 08.01.1908,
the Canadian Government passed an order-in-council that prohibited immigration
of persons who “in the opinion of the Minister of the Interior did not come
from the country of their birth or citizenship by a continuous journey and or
through tickets purchased before leaving the country of their birth or
nationality”. This Order was referred to as the “Asian Exclusion Act”.
(In other words, what it meant was that
“Can you do a Trapeze Act without a safety net, can you go through a ring of
fire without singeing yourself, can you come out alive from the lion’s den like
Androcles, or can you perform the twelve labours of Hercules? Only after we are
convinced that you can do all this, we will permit you to immigrate into Canada”).
What this immigration clause
actually meant was that it would
practically exclude immigration from India, and would apply to ships that began
their voyage in India as the huge distance from ports in India to Vancouver
would usually be covered with a necessary halt in Japan or Hawaii.
In 1913 alone,
Canada (which had opened its citizenship much earlier) took in over 400,000
immigrants almost all of whom had come from Europe, which number is a record of
sorts even to the present day.
The
inspiration behind undertaking the Voyage of the “Komagata Maru”:
Baba
Gurdit Singh Sandhu who hailed from Sarhali was a well-to
do fisherman in Singapore who was aware of the problems being faced by his
countrymen while immigrating to Canada due to the exclusion laws. To circumvent
this problem, he wanted to hire a ship to sail from Calcutta (present day
Kolkata, in India) to Vancouver, so that the obstacles faced by Indians due to
the discriminatory immigration laws in Canada would be circumvented, which had
hitherto come in the way.
Baba Gurdit Singh Sandhu,
who openly supported the “Ghadar” Party
(a “Revolutionary Party” founded by
Indians in Canada and the USA, which stood for complete Independence from the
British Raj), though aware of the discriminatory order-in-council of 1908 which
required a continuous voyage from the country of birth/origin, nevertheless,
was on a confrontation course with the Canadian immigration authorities,
against this discriminatory regulation and on pushing the cause of migrating
Indians to Canada, notwithstanding this “absurd” clause.
The
voyage of the “Komagata Maru” from
Hong Kong to Vancouver:
The “Komagata Maru” was a Japanese Steamship which sailed from Hong
Kong, Shanghai, China to Yokohama, Japan on its onward journey to Vancouver,
British Columbia, Canada in 1914. It carried on board 376 passengers consisting
of 340 Sikhs, 24 Muslims and 12 Hindus (all of them British subjects), who were
economic migrants from Punjab in the then British India, who did not like the
living conditions in India, where they were treated shabbily by the British Raj
Authorities.
After obtaining permission
to sail from the Hong Kong authorities, The “Komagata Maru” set sail from Hong Kong on 04.04.1914 with
165 passengers on board.
On 14.04.1914, the
vessel reached Yokohama.
On 03.05.1914, the
ship left Yokohama and sailed into Burrard Inlet, near Vancouver on 23.05.1914
with 376 passengers on board.
On
arrival at Vancouver:
Upon reaching Vancouver, the
“Komagata Maru” was not allowed to
dock and the passengers were not granted permission to disembark by the
immigration officials as the Asian Exclusion Law had already come into effect
requiring the ship to make a continuous journey from where it had started all
the way to Canada.
Pending a view to be taken
by the then Prime Minister of Canada – Robert Borden on the further course of
action as regards the fate of the passengers. In fact, a Conservative MP of British
Columbia – H.H. Stevens - organised a public meeting against allowing the passengers to disembark
and urged the Government not to do so and return the ship to the High Seas out
of Canadian waters. He worked in cahoots with the immigration officials to keep
the passengers from disembarking onto Canadian shores.
Meanwhile a “Shore
Committee” was formed by Indians resident in Canada and several protests
meetings were held in Canada and the USA. In fact, at meeting held in Dominion Hall, Vancouver,
it was resolved that if the passengers were not allowed to disembark, then, in
protest, all Indo-Canadians should follow them back to India and no one should
henceforth migrate to Canada from India. Strangely, the Canadian judiciary,
including a full Bench of the Court of Appeal unanimously refused to intervene
in the matter on grounds that it had no authority to interfere with the
decisions of the Department of Immigration and Colonisation. (A blatant case of the Judiciary being in
cahoots with the Immigration Authorities to keep the Indian passengers out of
Canada??).
The Prime Minister’s
decision also went against the Indian passengers and the Canadian Government
decided that a harbour tug the “Sea Lion” escorted by the HMCS Rainbow with
armed troops on board, should push the ship out to Sea. Accordingly, the “Komagata
Maru” after staying on the docks of Vancouver for two months was returned
to the High seas on 19.07.1914 on its return journey to India.
Not only that, during the
two months, that the Komagata Maru stayed on the docks, the Immigration
authorities denied food and water to them, but other Asian immigrants, who had
settled in Canada before the “Asian
Exclusion Act” came into effect, managed to give the passengers on
board the vessel some food and water.
Nevertheless, to save face against the public outrage,
the Immigration authorities allowed only 20 passengers (who had previously lived in Canada) to be admitted to Canadian
soil – on grounds that although the ship had violated the “exclusion clauses”,
these passengers did not have the required funds and they had not sailed
directly from India. (Wonder, if these
passengers had exhausted their monetary resources, by bribing the Canadian
Immigration authorities, who, conveniently, “bent the rules” to allow them into
Canada??).
The
Aftermath – at Canada:
The “Komagata Maru” incident was widely cited by Indian groups and other
sympathisers to highlight discrepancies in Canadian immigration laws &
several court cases sprung up in Canada.
A British Immigration
official who had a few Punjabi Indian locals supply him with information
designed to keep out the unfortunate passengers of the “Komagata Maru” off Canadian soil was gunned down along with two of
these locals at the Vancouver Courthouse while attending the ensuing trials
against the injustice meted out to the passengers of the ship.
The
Return voyage of the “Komagata Maru”:
The
Aftermath – at India:
As
the disappointed passengers, came back to India, they were in for another
shocking surprise, which violated at least another three Human Rights in the
end.
The “Komagata Maru” returned to India on 27.09.1914, where the
British Raj authorities, smarting from the considerable embarrassment faced by
Britain and Canada, caused by the public outrage world-wide, stopped the
Komagata Maru with a British gunboat and placed the passengers under guard on
the pretext that they were lawbreakers as well as dangerous political agitators
(I guess, if anyone would have had to
undergo the ordeal faced by the passengers of the Komagata Maru, they would be
perfectly justified to get agitated about the shabby treatment meted out to
them).
The vessel docked at Budge
Budge where the British Raj police went to arrest Baba Gurdit Singh and a score
of the men they perceived as the leaders of the group. The Baba resisted
arrest, a companion of his assaulted a policeman and a general melee ensued. The police immediately resorted to
indiscriminate firing upon the helpless unarmed passengers killing nineteen and
injuring several others. While some passengers, including the Baba, eluded the
Police dragnet/atrocities, while the others were arrested and sent to prison on
trumped up charges or returned to their villages.
Mahatma
Gandhi, the incorrigible pacifist, prevailed upon Baba Gurdit Singh Sandhu to
surrender to the British authorities and he was imprisoned to serve out a
prison term of five years.
Thus, the Komagata Maru
incident was not only the fault of Canada’s but also that of Britain. Both
countries violated the passenger’s rights, even though those rights had not
become officially recognised yet by international statutes like the Universal
Declaration of Human Rights.
In
Retrospect:
The Komagata Maru incident
violated at least three Human Rights Articles, as they stand defined today:
Article
3: Everyone has the right to life, liberty and security
of person. (This was violated when 19 persons were killed in the indiscriminate
police firing).
Article
9 (e): No one shall be subjected to arbitrary arrest,
detention or exile” (This was violated when the British gunboat tried to arrest
the 20 men they saw as the group leaders and opened fire indiscriminately on
them).
Article
13: Everyone has the right to leave any country,
including his own, and return to his country” (This was violated when the British
gun boat did not let them go back to their home country – India).
Memorials
to the “Komagata Maru” Incident:
In 1952, the
Government of India set up a memorial to the Komagata Maru martyrs near Budge
Budge. Popularly called the “Punjabi Monument” it is modelled as a “Kirpan” (meaning “dagger”) rising up
towards the sky.
On 23.07.1989, a
plaque commemorating the 75th Anniversary of the departure of
the Komagata Maru was placed at the Sikh Gurudwara in Vancouver, Canada.
In 1994, a plaque
commemorating the 80th Anniversary of the arrival of the
Komagata Maru was placed in the Vancouver harbour.
On 23.07.2012, a
monument in remembrance of the Komagata Maru incident was inaugurated near the
steps of the seawall that lead up to the Vancouver Convention Centre West
building in Coal Harbour.
The
Wheel turns a full Circle – Atonement:
On 23.06.2006, the
Conservative Government created the Community historical recognition programme,
in response to demands that the Canadian government should address historic
wrongs involving immigration. The programme provides grants and funding for
community projects linked to immigration restrictions as well as wartime
measures.
On 06.08.2006,
Prime Minister Harper in his address at the “Ghadri Babiyan da Mela” (meaning “Festival of the Ghadar Party”), in Surrey, British
Columbia stated that the Government of Canada acknowledged the “Komagata Maru”
incident and the Government’s resolve to “undertake consultations with the
Indo-Canadian community on how best to recognise this sad moment in Canada’s
history”.
On 03.04.2008, a
motion was tabled by an MP of Indian origin in the House of Commons which,
inter alia stated “that, in the opinion of the House, the government should
officially apologise to the Indo-Canadian community and to the individuals
impacted in the 1914 “Komagata Maru”
incident, in which the passengers were prevented from landing in Canada”. (The
Motion was passed on 15.05.2008 by the House after extensive debate as to the wordings thereof).
On 10.05.2008, the
Secretary of State (Multiculturalism and Canadian identity) announced that the
Indo-Canadian community could apply for up to $2.5 million in grants and
contributions funding to commemorate the “Komagata
Maru” incident.
In addition, on
23.05.2008, the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia unanimously passed a
Resolution that “this Legislature apologises for the events of May 23, 1914,
when 376 passengers of the Komagata Maru,
stationed off Vancouver harbour, were denied entry by Canada. The House
deeply regrets that the passengers, who sought refuge in our country and our
province, were turned away without benefit of the fair and impartial treatment
befitting a society where people of all cultures are welcomed and accepted”.
Later when attending the “13th Annual Babiyan da Mela”
on 03.08.2008, Prime Minister Harper said, that “On behalf of the Government of Canada, I am
officially conveying as Prime Minister of Canada that apology”. (the motions
passed by the House & Legislative Assembly).
Interestingly, the British
Columbia regiment which was involved in the expulsion of the "Komagata Maru" was
commanded by a Sikh Officer from 2011 onwards.
Also, in the recent
Parliamentary elections of the United Kingdom, the Prime Minister and leader of the
Conservative Party lobbied hard to get the vote of the now powerful Indian
community in Britain, by reaching out to them through statements/slogans
written in Hindi, the official language of India, a far cry when another
Conservative Party MP in Canada, conspired to have the Komagata Maru towed back to the
High Seas.
Other
Human Rights measures implemented in Canada:
Since signing of the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948, the Canadian government has
attempted to make human rights a part of Canadian Law. Four key mechanisms in
Canada have been put in place for protecting human rights:
- the
Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms,
- the
Canadian Human Rights Act
- the
Canadian Human rights Commission
- the
Provincial Human Rights Laws and Commissions.
Nevertheless, issues like
some Provinces still allowing the use of religiously segregated schools and the
treatment of Canada’s First Nations people or “Aboriginal Canadians” and the “disabled”
still have to be addressed.
Popular
literature & some other works on the Komagata Maru incident:
In January 1976, a
play, in Canada written by Sharon Pollock, titled “The Komagata Maru Incident” was presented.
In 1984, another
play “Komagata Maru” written by Ajmer
Rode was performed.
In 1989, a play commemorating
the 75th anniversary of the Komagata Maru Incident, by Sadhu Binning
and Sukhwant Hundal, titled “Samudari
Sher Nal Takkar” (meaning “The Encounter with the Sea-Lion”) was presented
in the first issue of Punjabi Literary Magazine – “Watan” (meaning “Motherland”).
In 2004, a feature
documentary “Continuous Journey” made by Ali Kazimi which took 8 years to make
and was inspired by meticulous research and rare footage of the ship at
Vancouver harbour. This Documentary won several Awards, including the Most
Innovative Canadian documentary at DOXA, Vancouver in 2005. Later, in 2012,
his book titled “Undesirables: White
Canada and the Komagata Maru” was published.
Commemoration
of the 100th Anniversary of the “Komagata
Maru” Incident:
On 01.05.2014, the Canada Post has released a stamp
commemorating the 100th Anniversary of the arrival of the “Komagata Maru”. The stamps are titled “Komagata Maru: 100th
Anniversary Collection”: (Booklet of six International Stamps).
The Government of India has announced that as a tribute to the
heroic struggle of Indian immigrants against the discriminatory immigration
laws of Canada in the early years of the twentieth century, the centenary of
the Komagata Maru incident would be
commemorated with a set of coins in the denominations of Rs.100/- and Rs. 5/-
which will be offered to Collectors as Proof and Uncirculated sets. Also, a
Rs.5/- coin has been released into general circulation in March 2015 by the
Reserve Bank of India.
From 29.09.2014 to 29.09.2015
several programmes commemorating the Incident have also been planned. An
International seminar titled “Komagata Maru: Context, Significance and Legacy”
and a play titled “Komagata Maru – 1914”, inter alia, are some of the
programmes being organised. In addition, a week-long function was held at
Vancouver from 23.05.2015 to 30.05.2015, which included cultural events,
seminars and exhibitions besides honouring the descendants of the Komagata Maru
passengers as well as non-Indians, including Canadians who rendered assistance
both financially and legally to the cause of the “Komagata Maru” passengers.
Commemorative Coin:
The Reserve Bank of India on behalf of the
Government of India has issued a five rupee coin in March 2015 to commemorate
the Centenary of the “Komagata Maru”
Incident for general circulation.
Reverse of the Five Rupee coin
issued on the occasion. The coin shows a depiction of the Japanese ship “Komagata Maru”. Along the periphery of
this face of the coin is the inscription “SHATABDI
SMARANOTSAV” (in Hindi/ Devnagri) on the upper right periphery and “CENTENARY
CELEBRATION” (in English) on the upper left periphery. On the right periphery
are the Commemoration years with the double dates “1914-2014”.
At the bottom are mentioned “KOMAGATA MARU INCIDENT”
(in English) and “KOMAGATA MARU PRASANG” in (Hindi/Devnagri).
Notice that on this face of the coin the “Diamond”
mint mark of the Mumbai Mint has been engraved on the bottom periphery just
above the inscription.
Obverse of the five Rupee coin.
This face shows the Lion Capital in the centre with the legend “Satyameva Jayate” (Truth will
Prevail/triumph). On the left periphery/flank is the word “Bharat”, in
Hindi/Devnagri script and on the right hand periphery/flank is mentioned
“India”, in English. On the bottom half of the coin is mentioned the
denominational value of the coin with the numeral “5”, preceded by the rupee
symbol.
The specifications
of the coin are:
Shape: Circular; Diameter: 23 mm; Number of
Serrations: 100; Metal Composition: Nickel Brass (Copper – 75%; Zinc – 20%;
Nickel – 5%).
A quote of Baba Gurdit Singh
Sandhu which inspired the passengers of the Komagata Maru to undertake the
perilous journey:
“The visions of men are
widened by travel and contacts with citizens of a free country will infuse a
spirit of independence and foster yearnings for freedom in the minds of
emasculated subjects of alien rule”.
(Apparently,
the “citizens” of the so called free countries – governed by discriminatory
regulations - as well as the “aliens” who were ruling his country thought
otherwise and ganged up against the noble ideals that the Baba stood for).
Posted on 21.05.2016:
Almost 102 years after Canada turned away the passengers of the "Komagata Maru", Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has formally apologised in Parliament for the "great injustice" that happened due to discriminatory laws of the time.
He apologised in the House of Commons on 18.04.2016 for the 1914 decision by the then Canadian government to turn away the migrants on board the ship after their arrival in Vancouver. He added "Canada's government was, without question, responsible for the laws that prevented these passengers from immigrating peacefully and securely. For that and every regrettable consequence that followed, we are sorry". He further added that Canada's current defence minister Harjit Sajjan once commanded the Reserve Regiment that turned back the Komagata Maru and thanked him for helping the ship incident get national attention.
Posted on 21.05.2016:
Almost 102 years after Canada turned away the passengers of the "Komagata Maru", Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has formally apologised in Parliament for the "great injustice" that happened due to discriminatory laws of the time.
He apologised in the House of Commons on 18.04.2016 for the 1914 decision by the then Canadian government to turn away the migrants on board the ship after their arrival in Vancouver. He added "Canada's government was, without question, responsible for the laws that prevented these passengers from immigrating peacefully and securely. For that and every regrettable consequence that followed, we are sorry". He further added that Canada's current defence minister Harjit Sajjan once commanded the Reserve Regiment that turned back the Komagata Maru and thanked him for helping the ship incident get national attention.
Posted
on 19.07.2016:
I have yesterday received
a Commemorative Uncirculated Rs.5/- Coin from the Hyderabad Mint on the
Centenary of the Komagata Maru Incident:
The Cover of the Album
containing the Commemorative Rs.5/- coin.
The Cover shows the passenger ship
the “Komagata Maru”, with the initial “K” on its single funnel sailing on the
Pacific Ocean. The inscriptions on the album are “Smarak Sikka” (in Hindi) and “COMMEMORATIVE COIN” (in English) and “Komagatu Maru Prasang – Shatabdi Smaranotsav
– 1914-2014” (in Hindi) and “CENTENARY COMMEMORATION OF KOMAGATA MARU INCIDENT
1914-2014”.
The inner pages 2 and 3 of
the Coin Album
Page 2 of the Coin Album
The text on this page
reads, inter alia:
“On May 23, 1914, Komagata
Maru, a Japanese steamer, carrying 376 passengers from Hong Kong, mostly
immigrants from Punjab, British India, arrived in Vancouver City in Canada. It
was denied docking by the Canadian authorities. Following a two month
stalemate, the ship was escorted out of the harbour by the Canadian Military
and forced to sail back to India. The Komagata Maru arrived in Calcutta in
September 1914. The British Imperial Government saw the men on Komagata Maru as
dangerous political agitators. The police went aboard the ship on 29th
September, 1914 to arrest Baba Gurdit Singh and other leaders. The arrest was
resisted by the passengers which led to police firing in which 19 passengers
were killed. Baba Gurdit Singh escaped along with many others. The rest of the
passengers were sent to Punjab.
As a tribute to the heroic
struggle of the Indian immigrants against the discriminatory immigration laws
of Canada in the early years of the twentieth century, the Government of India
has commemorated the centenary of Komagata Maru Incident.”
Page 3 of the Coin Album
shows the ship Komagata Maru, with its passengers on board along
with the Obverse image of the Rs.5/- coin
The specifications of this coin:
Denomination:
Rs.5/-; Metallic Composition:
Nickel-Brass: Copper-75%, Zinc – 20%, Nickel – 5%.
The Obverse of the coin
The Obverse of the coin shows the Emblem of the Government of
India – the Lion Capitol, together with the inscription “Satyameva Jayate
(meaning “Truth Always Prevails”). The country name is given on the left and
right peripheries – “Bharat” in Hindi) and “India” (in English). The
denomination of the coin “Rs.5” is given at the bottom of this face.
Pages 4 and 5 of the Coin Album
Page 4 of the Coin Album
contains the Reverse of the coin, an image of the memorial stone for the victims of the Komagata
Maru at Budge Budge.
It also gives more specifications
of this coin:
Dimensions:
Diameter:
23.00 mm; Weight: 6.00 gms; No. of Serrations: 100
The Reverse of the coin
The Reverse of the coin shows the Komagata Maru in the centre,
with the upper peripheral inscriptions “CENTENARY COMMEMORATION. Shatabdi Smaranotsav – 1914-2014. The
lower peripheral inscription reads “KOMAGATA MARU INCIDENT. Komagata Maru Prasang”. The star mint
mark of the Hyderabad Mint is below the image of the ship.
The Memorial Stone reads “To
THE MEMORY OF THE MARTYRS OF “KOMAGATA MARU”, SEPTEMBER 29, 1914” UNVEILED BY SRI JAWAHARLAL NEHRU PRIME
MINISTER OF INDIA JANUARY 1, 1952”.
Page 5 of the Coin Album
shows an image of the Coin’s Reverse and a photograph of the ship Komagata Maru
on the shores and being prevented by Canadian authorities to dock and off-load
passengers for immigration to Canada.
The Back Cover of the Coin
Album gives a brief description about the Hyderabad Mint.
(The above circulation coin has been
given for my collection by Krishna Tonpe. Article researched and written and
coin images scanned by Rajeev Prasad)
Ramchandra Lalingkar has commented:
ReplyDelete"Very nice information. I am sending this information to my 'son-in-law' Mr.Phillip Ernest who is from Canada and married to my youngest daughter in 2006 . He has done Ph.D. in Sanskrit from Cambridge University and his subject of study is 'Mahabharat'. Let me get his reaction to the information in the post".
Thank you, Lalingkar sahab. Great to know about Phillip's interest in ancient Indian languages and mythology. Will wait for his reaction. I hope I have not gone "overboard" in my assessment of the Canadian response to Indian/Asian immigration around early twentieth century on this incident. (:-)
DeleteRamchandra Lalingkar has commented:
Delete"Not at all. In fact Mr.Phillip is very practical and pragmatic".
Sumita did not like a few of my personal "observations" and wanted them out. I have since edited some of these "observations". But I have "managed" to keep a few of them in the post. (:-)
DeleteGds Banga has commented:
ReplyDelete"He (Justin Trudeau) is a decent man. But apologies are uncalled for. You cannot travel back in time and say for people who were governing your country at that time. Can you recreate the scene and sentiments why the act took place? Were the rulers then anti national? So let us live to create a better today and better tomorrow. AS PER OUR WISDOM. Tomorrow that may also be questioned. And we should not expect apologies for any past acts nor demand them."
In the Canadian Parliament and in the Sikh community in Canada, such an apology has been a long outstanding demand. I guess that as you have rightly said, after this apology, it is time to put this behind and move on. This is also what Trudeau has in mind when he tendered this unqualified apology.
DeleteDear sir I am I have this coin for sale please help me thank you
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing this interesting article. Your efforts are greatly appreciated. for immigration to Canada, you can visit Canada immigration from India
ReplyDelete